Your Opinion, Please?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2020 3:03 pm
Hello ...
I am in the process of self-publishing a non-fiction book heavily based on interviews with people who have been involved in a variety of wilderness emergencies. These people are search and rescue personnel, subjects of operations, families involved, police and fire personnel, and so on. Those interviewed represent a wide cross-section of people involved in emergency operations.
I have received an editor's opinion that the verbatim quotes obtained from these interviews should be excluded from the book if they contain swear words, a sexist comment, or say rude things about another person. On some other quotes, the editor wants to alter the quotes so the stories "flow better", are grammatically correct, and are sanitized to make sure various organizations appear "more professional". Her reasoning here is that readers will be more accepting of properly constructed memories than the rather earthy and from-the-heart statements made by certain interviewees.
I am hesitant to act on the editor's input as the quotes were obtained in interviews where there was a high level of trust between the person being interviewed and myself. I do not want to betray that trust by cleaning up the emotional or passionate memories given to me so some readers won't be offended.
At some level, I feel that editing or deleting quotes obtained in interviews is a form of censorship. And yet, I am not a professional editor and don't know if this is advice I should act on or advice I should reject out of hand. I am leaning towards rejecting the advice, but would like to hear from others who may have an opinion on this matter.
Thank you for considering this question. Looking forward to the responses. This is my first post on this forum.
All the best.
I am in the process of self-publishing a non-fiction book heavily based on interviews with people who have been involved in a variety of wilderness emergencies. These people are search and rescue personnel, subjects of operations, families involved, police and fire personnel, and so on. Those interviewed represent a wide cross-section of people involved in emergency operations.
I have received an editor's opinion that the verbatim quotes obtained from these interviews should be excluded from the book if they contain swear words, a sexist comment, or say rude things about another person. On some other quotes, the editor wants to alter the quotes so the stories "flow better", are grammatically correct, and are sanitized to make sure various organizations appear "more professional". Her reasoning here is that readers will be more accepting of properly constructed memories than the rather earthy and from-the-heart statements made by certain interviewees.
I am hesitant to act on the editor's input as the quotes were obtained in interviews where there was a high level of trust between the person being interviewed and myself. I do not want to betray that trust by cleaning up the emotional or passionate memories given to me so some readers won't be offended.
At some level, I feel that editing or deleting quotes obtained in interviews is a form of censorship. And yet, I am not a professional editor and don't know if this is advice I should act on or advice I should reject out of hand. I am leaning towards rejecting the advice, but would like to hear from others who may have an opinion on this matter.
Thank you for considering this question. Looking forward to the responses. This is my first post on this forum.
All the best.