Robert Tulip wrote:Harper Lee’s description of Bob Ewell is highly detailed, and dripping with contempt, as is her classic account of the Ewell residence – trash is as trash does.
This is one of the more problematic aspects of the book. By tossing us a villain, and one from contemptible social status, Lee is inviting us to feel superior to those who lie for the preservation of their meager status. I am not denying that such people, and such lineages, exist. (Apparently one of them, the Pooles of Northern Pennsylvania and Southern upstate New York, includes a member of my ancestral lineage). I just resist reducing the dynamics of racism to that one oversimplified narrative. In a book that shines with the beauty of a little girl treating everyone as "just folks" the same as everyone else, it's a jarring gash of sneering hostility.
Every town the size of Maycomb had families like the Ewells. No economic fluctuations changed their status—people like the Ewells lived as guests of the county in prosperity as well as in the depths of a depression. No truant officers could keep their numerous offspring in school; no public health officer could free them from congenital defects, various worms, and the diseases indigenous to filthy surroundings. Maycomb’s Ewells lived behind the town garbage dump in what was once a Negro cabin.
The redemptive moment comes when Atticus asks Mayella if she has any friends. Along with some processing afterward, we get to see her loneliness as the reason Tom Robinson was singled out for exploitation and eventually for execution. Her father is too far gone to do the chores, and she imposes on Robinson to do them, but it turns out loneliness was the true motivation.
The good ladies of Maycomb, like her aunt Alexandra, would never deign to mingle with Mayella Ewing. Their Christianity does not extend to lepers. Lee's jaundiced eye takes it all in, and she can see the sadness of the wreckage that leads to Robinson's horrible death. Just in case we didn't see the workings of caste in the situation, Lee twists the knife with the irony of the prosecutor's seizure of Tom Robinson's pity as the nail in his coffin. "You felt sorry for her?" That is, of course, absolutely too much insult to be tolerated.
After recently reading an excellent book about trauma, it's easy to imagine the generations of abuse behind Mayella's plight. There are hints in the text ("what her father did with her didn't count" for example) of incest, reputed to be rife in the world of Appalachian hillbillies from which the Ewings are not far removed. Incest victims are often themselves torn apart inside and, even if the outside world would give them the time of day, are not able to receive it. I am just starting Delia Owens' "Where the Crawdads Sing", which seems to be about a world like that of the Ewings. Bob Ewing was no doubt beaten by his (probably alcoholic) father, and crumpled into alcoholism before he even had a chance to find his footing as a productive citizen. I met a few young people caught in intergenerational transmission of abuse even in the pretty suburbs of Southern California. Not a pretty sight.
One corner of the yard, though, bewildered Maycomb. Against the fence, in a line, were six chipped-enamel slop jars holding brilliant red geraniums, cared for as tenderly as if they belonged to Miss Maudie Atkinson, had Miss Maudie deigned to permit a geranium on her premises. People said they were Mayella Ewell’s.
I looked up "slop jar" and Dr. Duck Duck Goose confirmed my suspicion that it is a polite term for "chamber pot". Here we have another symbolism that can be heartwrenching if you dwell on it. Mayella wanted a few flowers, settling for the hardy and easily transferred ordinariness of geraniums, and she planted them in chamber pots discarded by folks who had presumably acquired indoor plumbing.
Robert Tulip wrote: Atticus extracts the confirmation, under a cross examination that Scout compares to Sherlock Holmes, that Ewell endorses the sheriff’s account of Mayella’s injuries, whereat his astute court-watching children infer that the bruising on her right is consistent with battery by her left-handed father.
The movie made this point a bit more explicit, and heightened the drama, but the subtleties in the book's presentation were admirable. For example we get to see the carelessness with which Bob Ewell (and Mayella and the sheriff) have ignored the obvious inability of crippled Tom Robinson to do the deed of which he is accused, because they know the evidence doesn't matter (reminds me of Ted Cruz and Josh Hawley). The point at which Ewell recognizes he has been exposed, but switches quickly to a new variant on the lie. The agitation among the Black citizens of Maycomb after the trial, having had the truth laid out for them in a way they know none of their White neighbors could have missed.