Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Author
Message
Jeremy1952
Doctorate
Joined: Oct 2002 Posts: 554 Location: Saint Louis
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Part of Diamond's case is that humans have demonstrated in numerous ways that we will exploit the material available to us. When one group of humans goes thousands of years longer than another domesticating local crops, the greater agriculture success of one group as compared to the other could be almost entirely due to the variety of candidate crops that happen to grow in that group's territory.
This strikes me of evidence in favor of the Gould/"constraints" view of evolution in general, and against the Dawkins/"Whatever is Needed" view. This is especially interesting to me because my inclination is usually toward Dawkins. Dawkins', and Darwin's, view of evolution is that the necessary variation will probably show up sooner or later, so it is the selective pressure that matters most. It seems to me that if cultural evolution can be shown to be strongly related to the botanic raw material available, then it points toward biological evolution being constrained by possible paths as opposed to evolving into whatever niche is available.
Sat Feb 08, 2003 9:57 pm
ZachSylvanus
Sophomore
Joined: Aug 2002 Posts: 283 Location: Fort Collins, CO
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Lan: The evolutionary trait in question here could be seen to be domesticating crops, in which case it evolved in each instance. That the crops available were themselves harder to cultivate in the latter case than the former isn't under the control of humans, and therefore changes the niche to be filled.
Sat Feb 08, 2003 10:59 pm
Jeremy1952
Doctorate
Joined: Oct 2002 Posts: 554 Location: Saint Louis
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Yes... I was thinking more in terms of analogy, however, than correllation.
To be more specific: Available plant species are to agriculture as available alleles are to adaptation. Edited by: Jeremy1952 at: 2/9/03 8:08:19 am
Sun Feb 09, 2003 12:03 am
ZachSylvanus
Sophomore
Joined: Aug 2002 Posts: 283 Location: Fort Collins, CO
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
I'd be willing to say that's a faulty analogy, based on the fact that mutation is a random process, and so "available alleles" aren't really constrained in any way other than that you can only have x many. While it is true that evolution is constrained by available alleles (if you don't have an allele to process vent chemicals for energy, you won't be doing so), that doesn't mean that such alleles won't eventually become available, as per Dawkins and Darwin.
Remember Jeremy: Much of Punctuated Equilibrium can be shown to not apply to vertebrate evolution--the entire theory was based off of prehistoric marine invertebrates.
Sun Feb 09, 2003 3:04 pm
Jeremy1952
Doctorate
Joined: Oct 2002 Posts: 554 Location: Saint Louis
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Zach
Quote:I'd be willing to say that's a faulty analogy, based on the fact that mutation is a random process, and so "available alleles" aren't really constrained in any way other than that you can only have x many. While it is true that evolution is constrained by available alleles (if you don't have an allele to process vent chemicals for energy, you won't be doing so), that doesn't mean that such alleles won't eventually become available, as per Dawkins and Darwin.
Remember Jeremy: Much of Punctuated Equilibrium can be shown to not apply to vertebrate evolution--the entire theory was based off of prehistoric marine invertebrates.
My sympathies lie more with Dawkins than with Gould. I find it interesting food for thought, however. Your analysis of the analogy strikes me as circular. In essence, you have said that evidence of constraint can't be valid because constraint isn't valid. Assuming the conclusion, in other words.
Mutation may be random, but a mutation can't become an allele unless its organism survives; thus, constraint. The core difference of opinion is how much constraint vs. how much variation. Nobody denies that both exist.
Sun Feb 09, 2003 6:55 pm
ZachSylvanus
Sophomore
Joined: Aug 2002 Posts: 283 Location: Fort Collins, CO
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Jeremy, I didn't say that constraint is not valid, I implied that constraint is negligible given a sufficient timeline.
Sun Feb 09, 2003 8:02 pm
Jeremy1952
Doctorate
Joined: Oct 2002 Posts: 554 Location: Saint Louis
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Agreed
Mon Feb 10, 2003 7:14 pm
Chris OConnor
Rhodes Scholar
Joined: May 2002 Posts: 10157 Location: Florida Highscores:33 Thanks: 228 Thanked: 89 times in 75 posts
Gender: Country:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Jeremy
Damn I wish you had been around for the discussion of Jared Diamonds "Guns, Germs, And Steel." Overall the discussion forum was relatively inactive, even though Jared Diamond had agreed to be our geust in the chat room. Maybe we can redo this book down the line.
Joined: Oct 2002 Posts: 554 Location: Saint Louis
Thanks: 0 Thanked: 0 time in 0 post
Gender:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Thanks. I'm enjoying the book imensely; on the other hand, I have to admit it isn't an easy read at all. Also the comments I've made are peripheral to what Diamond is talking about. I'll have more to say about his main thesis when I've finished the book.
Tue Feb 11, 2003 11:04 am
Chris OConnor
Rhodes Scholar
Joined: May 2002 Posts: 10157 Location: Florida Highscores:33 Thanks: 228 Thanked: 89 times in 75 posts
Gender: Country:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
In some ways I think Pinker and Diamond are at odds with each other. We should definitely put "The Blank Slate" on the poll for May & June. In fact, I'm going to post a poll right now in the book suggestion forum pertaining to a new idea for our book polls. Check it out. ChrisEdited by: Chris OConnor at: 10/30/05 3:38 pm
Tue Feb 11, 2003 12:12 pm
Chris OConnor
Rhodes Scholar
Joined: May 2002 Posts: 10157 Location: Florida Highscores:33 Thanks: 228 Thanked: 89 times in 75 posts
Gender: Country:
Re: Guns, Germs, and Steel two: Constraints and Niches
Jeremy:
I moved this thread to this forum since it pertains to Guns, Germs and Steel. These book forums never die so feel free to continue the discussions even when we have moved to another book.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
The ancient philosopher Plato
held that God is revealed
locally through a Demiurge, an
artisan-like figure
responsible for the fashioning
and maintenance of the
physical universe.… more
Have you ever considered one
day sitting down and tracing
your family history?
Don't get me wrong it
takes more than one day but
you get my drift I hope.
Today with the… mor
e
You'll now notice a brand
new widget available for your
personal blog called the
"Poll Widget." You
can add polls to your sidebar
simply by dragging and
dropping the… more
So our garden is beginning to
produce an abundance of
tomatoes zucchini and even
some green peppers. The
cantaloupes are getting bigger
and one is starting to turn
beige. I don… more
In America we spend far more
of our time ordering food than
making it it seems, and yet,
when it comes to either phone
ordering OR counter ordering
we don't seem to have a
clu… more
From
http://www.bautforum.com/showt
hread.php/106667-Evolution-cla
rifications?p=1777341#post1777
341
Part of the debate here turns
on the question of whether
evolution displays
prog… more
Oh, University. Much like
everything else in my life, if
I don't have it, I want
it. I'm currently waiting
to get back to university and
just sitting here in boring
Orang… more
The Butterfield Stage line
between Warner’s Ranch and Oak
Grove was a narrow trail,
dusty in summer, soggy in
winter, rutted the year
round. On its weekly treks,
the stage always…
more
I went out into my garden
today to find that something
had eaten all of my parsley.
It turns out I have about 50
Black Swallowtail caterpillars
munching away at my
garden.
Since starting with Herodotus,
I've read The Will of
Zeus by Stringfellow Barr, as
well as Thucydides' The
Peloponnesian War. I've
also read the Rise and Fall of
Ath… more
Once the heart stops beating,
blood collects in the most
dependent parts of the
body (livor mortis), the body
stiffens (rigor mortis), and
the body begins to cool
(alg… more
In folklore, werewolves are
people who sometimes
shapeshift into wolves.
Because werewolves are usually
thought to be part of the
supernatural, they are seldom
investigated by pe…
more
If you enjoy business bestsellers and would like to expand your business knowledge check out the quality book summaries offered by the world's leading book summary company.
BookTalk.org is a free book discussion group or online reading group or book club. We read and talk about both fiction and non-fiction books as a group. We host live author chats where booktalk members can interact with and interview authors. We give away free books to our members in book giveaway contests. Our booktalks are open to everybody who enjoys talking about books. Our book forums include book reviews, author interviews and book resources for readers and book lovers. Discussing books is our passion. We're a literature forum, or reading forum. Register a free book club account today! Suggest nonfiction and fiction books. Authors and publishers are welcome to advertise their books or ask for an author chat or author interview.
Tweet This Topic
at: 10/30/05 3:38 pm
