| BookTalk.org News |
| • The Secret Garden has won the Dec. 2008 Jan. 2009 Fiction book poll! |
| • Thank you Ophelia!!! Your donation is MUCH appreciated! |
| • Thank you for your very generous donation Interbane! |
| • 5 members are now enjoying the new "Email Digests" feature. Click on the digests link on the right at the top of every page to learn more. This is a great feature for keeping updated on forum activity. |
| • Regular casual chats are back on the menu! Check out the calendar for the schedule. |
| Featured Videos |
BREAKING NEWS

Andrew Bacevich
"The Limits of Power"

More Videos
|
| Amazon Honor System |
|
| Donate to BookTalk.org |
Please support BookTalk.org by making a small donation today!
•
Who supports us?
|
| Show us where you live! |
 |
|
| Author |
Message |
Chris OConnor  Rhodes Scholar BookTalk.org Owner

Usergroups: None
Joined: 05 May 2002
     
Posts: 7267
Thanks Given: 46 Received: 16 in 14 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Florida

|
Posted: Sat May 24, 2008 1:31 am Post subject: Moron Alert: California Man Sees Virgin Mary In Wound
|
|
|
California Man Believes He Sees Virgin Mary In Wound
http://www.wlbz2.com/news/watercooler/article.aspx?storyid=86461
MONTEREY, CA (NBC) -- A California man says he can see the image of the Virgin Mary in his leg after a motorcycle accident.
See, God does work in mysterious ways.
Marc Lipton said he was riding his motorcycle when he lost control and slid about 50 feet along the road.
Lipton said he wasn't wearing leather chaps at the time because he was close to home.
Ahhh, that makes sense. The softness of the pavement is related to the proximity of ones home. Brilliant.
Lipton said he believes the Virgin Mary protected him from further injury when the motorcycle slid out from underneath him.
The Roman Catholic Church has very strict guidelines regarding what is deemed an official sighting of the Virgin Mary.
There has been no word on if the Diocese of Monterey will investigate Lipton's leg as a legitimate apparition of the Virgin Mary. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Constance963  Intern

Usergroups: None
Joined: 20 Nov 2007

Posts: 165
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 

|
Posted: Tue Jun 03, 2008 11:45 am Post subject: Re: Moron Alert: California Man Sees Virgin Mary In Wound
|
|
|
| Chris OConnor wrote: |
Ahhh, that makes sense. The softness of the pavement is related to the proximity of ones home. Brilliant.
|
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Penelope  Stupendously Brilliant Silver Contributor


Usergroups: None
Joined: 02 Oct 2007

Posts: 737
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Cheshire, England

|
Posted: Tue Jun 03, 2008 12:36 pm Post subject:
|
|
|
Chris O'Connor - Listen to me....because I am nobody.....
It must make you so mad....that people who believe that there is more to life than meets the eye....see significance in apparitions....of 'the virgin' in their leg wounds.....
After Princess Diana died....people thought that they saw her image in the clouds........that is their emotional reaction.....
But please.....believe that some of us have a modicum of intelligence.....
I believe that there is much, much, much more to life than meets the eye...and I get even madder than you........honest I do!!!!! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Thomas Hood  Sophomore Book Discussion Leader

Usergroups: None
Joined: 17 Feb 2008
Posts: 281
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 3 in 3 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Wyse Fork, NC

|
Posted: Tue Jun 03, 2008 8:27 pm Post subject:
|
|
|
The main impediment to human welfare in my opinion is neither pareidolia nor apophenia but dis-pareidolia and dis-apophenia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Wegener
"By the 1930s, Wegener's geological work was almost universally dismissed by the scientific community and remained obscure for some thirty years."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis
"Semmelweis was outraged by the indifference of the medical profession and began writing open and increasingly angry letters to prominent European obstetricians, at times denouncing them as irresponsible murderers. His contemporaries, including his wife, believed he was losing his mind and he was in 1865 committed to an asylum (mental institution). Semmelweis died there only 14 days later, possibly after being severely beaten by guards."
Tom |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Penelope  Stupendously Brilliant Silver Contributor


Usergroups: None
Joined: 02 Oct 2007

Posts: 737
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Cheshire, England

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 6:17 am Post subject:
|
|
|
Thomas Hood: - I don't think I have ever spoken to you before....that is, I don't think I have responded to any of your posts....but I do read them.
I do find your language 'esoteric'...more even than my most admired, Robert Tulip. Still, I do realise that we need to have words and terms to signify complicated 'mind sets'......it is just that if we are not all used to the same terms.....we have a language barrier.....and we all speak 'English'....
Oh, isn't it difficult?
pareidolia - can you clarify what this means please?
apophenia - and this word, I have never heard......but I do know that they both appear to have Greek roots......(just so that you know I am not completely stupid).
I am really, truely interested in what you are saying......but I am losing something in the translation, I think. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Chris OConnor  Rhodes Scholar BookTalk.org Owner

Usergroups: None
Joined: 05 May 2002
     
Posts: 7267
Thanks Given: 46 Received: 16 in 14 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Florida

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 8:15 am Post subject:
|
|
|
Penelope
| Quote: |
| Chris O'Connor - Listen to me....because I am nobody..... |
You don't have to have impressive credentials to earn my respect. Just be a clear thinker and be able to present a logical argument.
| Quote: |
| It must make you so mad....that people who believe that there is more to life than meets the eye....see significance in apparitions....of 'the virgin' in their leg wounds..... |
Mad? No, it doesn't make me mad at all. I feel sad. When I see grown adults that have so little ability to differentiate between reality and fantasy I feel saddened. What went wrong in their life experiences to allow them to miss the same lessons that taught me and most critical thinkers to think soundly? It's sad. People believing in a God or gods, witches, astral projection astrology, UFO's, demons, Satan, faith healing, etc...
When I get past the sad feeling I move into the scared feeling. I'm genuinely scared that my vote can easily be countered by the vote of someone who sees visions in Corn Flakes or in their scabbing leg wounds. I think there ought to be some sort of test to make sure people are mentally competent before they are allowed to participate in complex societal decisions. But that wouldn't be democratic now would it?
| Quote: |
| After Princess Diana died....people thought that they saw her image in the clouds........that is their emotional reaction..... |
Yep, ignorant people saw such things. But Diana wasn't in the clouds...just in the minds of ignorant or overly emotional people. So because many people had delusions we should accept delusional thinking as on par with clear and logical thinking? I don't think so.
| Quote: |
| But please.....believe that some of us have a modicum of intelligence..... |
Saying something is so doesn't make it so. Intelligent people make intelligent decisions and statements. They form intelligent arguments. Intelligent people typically appear inteligent.
| Quote: |
| I believe that there is much, much, much more to life than meets the eye...and I get even madder than you........honest I do!!!!! |
Great, you "believe" such things. Now show me why you believe these things. A critical thinker can demonstrate the why of their beliefs. If they can't explain why they believe something they typically discard the belief as emotional or irrational.
My posts aren't about me getting "mad," but about me being disgusted with morons. A moron has just as much voting power as a genius. Is this fair? What if, by way of random events, morons became the majority? Should public policy be controlled by morons?
By the way I use "strong" language to make points. I'm aware that each word chosen, such as "moron," is not always applicable. But the general principle is solid as hell. Obviously, everyone who believes in a God is not a moron. But they are clearly delusional, as Richard Dawkins argued in "The God Delusion." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Penelope  Stupendously Brilliant Silver Contributor


Usergroups: None
Joined: 02 Oct 2007

Posts: 737
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Cheshire, England

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 9:05 am Post subject:
|
|
|
Chris.....to me it is irrational....not to notice that in this life.....there are some things which we cannot explain scientifically.
And...just as you are appalled that people who are delusional....are allowed a vote......I get very scared that people.....with no sense of the infinite...no sense of an eternal soul.... in all of us.....often, rise to positions of great power.
We cannot prove that we have a 'soul', Chris....but we can feel it.
How can I provide a 'logical' argument when all I have is an emotion to go on......but I do insist....that my emotion is just as tangible (OK, not logical) as your intellect.
I do think that we need to have a foot in both worlds if we are to get anywhere. Because, I agree, all would be chaos and confusion if we gave too much emphasis to our 'spiritual' natures. But it would be a pretty dead and meaningless world if all we knew and felt could be scientifically explained and diagnosed. Hitler would have been right for a start.....let's create a super-race....let's exterminate all those who do not meet our criteria.....as strong, intelligent superbeings....
And....if we did that.....what would we become?......Strong...intelligent and soul-less Zombies.
It is a matter of balance...... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Thomas Hood  Sophomore Book Discussion Leader

Usergroups: None
Joined: 17 Feb 2008
Posts: 281
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 3 in 3 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Wyse Fork, NC

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 11:48 am Post subject:
|
|
|
| Penelope wrote: |
| Thomas Hood: - I don't think I have ever spoken to you before....that is, I don't think I have responded to any of your posts....but I do read them. |
Thank you, Penelope. I have read many of yours too.
| Quote: |
I do find your language 'esoteric'...more even than my most admired, Robert Tulip. Still, I do realise that we need to have words and terms to signify complicated 'mind sets'......it is just that if we are not all used to the same terms.....we have a language barrier.....and we all speak 'English'....
Oh, isn't it difficult? |
More esoteric than Robert? Well, that is because speaking isn't necessary any more. Like the scientists of Laputa, we can now communicate by holding up quotations from Wikipedia Pareidolia occurs in internet discussion of Marc Lipton's Virgin Mary.
| Quote: |
| pareidolia - can you clarify what this means please? |
Pareidolia refers to seeing unintended or imaginary objects like the Virgin Mary or the face on Mars. Apophenia refers to seening patterns that are unintended or imaginary.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareidolia
"The term pareidolia (pronounced /pæraɪˈdoʊliə/), referenced in 1994 by Steven Goldstein,[1] describes a psychological phenomenon involving a vague and random stimulus (often an image or sound) being perceived as significant. Common examples include images of animals or faces in clouds, the man in the moon, and hidden messages on records played in reverse."
Marc Lipton's Virgin Mary experience is an example of pareidolia. Last week my sister wanted me to kill a pareidoliac snake in her dance hall. The snake turned out to be an extension cord.
| Quote: |
| apophenia - and this word, I have never heard......but I do know that they both appear to have Greek roots......(just so that you know I am not completely stupid). |
I'll never think that the person who beat me in identifying The Scarlet Letter in Name That Book! is stupid -- even if you see apparitions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophenia
"Apophenia is the experience of seeing patterns or connections in random or meaningless data. The term was coined in 1958 by Klaus Conrad, who defined it as the "unmotivated seeing of connections" accompanied by a "specific experience of an abnormal meaningfulness". Apophenia is often used as an explanation of some paranormal and religious claims, and can also be used to explain the tendency of humans to believe pseudoscience such as Intelligent design. Apophenia may be linked to psychosis and creativity." The search for Bible codes and much Kabbalistic interpretation are examples of 'apophenia'.
| Quote: |
| I am really, truely interested in what you are saying......but I am losing something in the translation, I think. |
My objection to the terms pareidolia and apophenia is that they conceal a value judgment that discounts imagination and restricts meaning to the supposed literal. Most of life's important things are in the shadows, in allusion and symbol. Things we seriously value are seldom put in the brightest light.
I, of course, am being defensive as I am often accused of seeing things by those who neglect contextual evidence. A recent example:
| Quote: |
| Tom… I’m going to be boringly literal-minded about this. The taotie is part of the cast bronze [of a ding], the sixth line isn’t part of the lower nuclear trigram, and it does actually say ‘jade handle’. So I expect it means ‘jade handle’. |
Tom
P.S. I did attempt to post about home remedies for styes to you blog, but my message went missing in cyberspace. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Chris OConnor  Rhodes Scholar BookTalk.org Owner

Usergroups: None
Joined: 05 May 2002
     
Posts: 7267
Thanks Given: 46 Received: 16 in 14 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Florida

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 11:52 am Post subject:
|
|
|
| Quote: |
| Chris.....to me it is irrational....not to notice that in this life.....there are some things which we cannot explain scientifically. |
Name a few of these "unexplainables" so that I can be sure I follow your logic. By saying "we cannot explain" do you mean we don't yet understand these things? ...or are you saying that actually trying to understand them is a fruitless endeavor? And if this is your point what is your evidence? How do you know that there are things that science cannot ever explain?
And what makes you think atheists and scientists don't notice the things you notice? We simply draw different conclusions. When we see something mysterious and awe-inspiring we set out to understand it. Theists throw their hands up in the air and say, "Wow, magic!" Before you roll your eyes really think about your God belief. What is God other than a magical answer to questions?
I'd like a further explanation of your statement so I can understand your argument. What can't we understand? Love? Happiness? The origins of life? What specifically are you talking about?
| Quote: |
| And...just as you are appalled that people who are delusional....are allowed a vote......I get very scared that people.....with no sense of the infinite...no sense of an eternal soul.... in all of us.....often, rise to positions of great power. |
What does "infinite" really mean? Seriously, explain this in detail. What do you observe that you can classify as infinite? The universe? How does an infinite universe lead you to believe in the Christian God?
Eternal soul? You actually "sense" an eternal soul? Which "senses" do you employ to sense this eternal soul? Your sight? Your hearing? Explain this sensory experience to me in detail, please. I'd like to "sense an eternal soul" too, so maybe you can help me with this.
Let me see if I know what you're going to say before you even say it.
These are the steps of a theist:
Step 1: Believe
Step 2: Experience
These are the steps of an atheist:
Step 1: Experience
Step 2: Believe
Notice a difference?
So you said you feel sorry for people that cannot sense an eternal soul. Help me learn how to sense this eternal soul. Do I need to first believe in an eternal soul prior to being able to experience or "sense" it? What if I believe in bow-legged immaterial unicorns? Will I now "sense" them? Actually, science tells us that delusional people that believe in things will often "sense" them even if those things don't really exist. Do I want to force myself into this situation?
No, I'd rather "sense" this eternal soul before believing in it. So how do I sense it? What does it smell like? How heavy is it? Is it lighter or heavier than air? Are these questions silly and irrelevant? How so? It was you that said you feel sorry for people that cannot sense what you can easily sense, so share with me the simple sensory experience.
Ahhh....you don't really "sense" it at all, do you? You didn't really mean to use that word. You infer a soul must exist because this crazy world blows you away and you just cannot fathom your life ending when you die. Not good enough. Your confusion doesn’t necessitate a God.
Back to the statement about the difference between theists and scientists and atheists. We too are blown away by this crazy world. We're so blown away that we dedicate our lives and brains to trying to understand it.
| Quote: |
| We cannot prove that we have a 'soul', Chris....but we can feel it. |
Where do you "feel" it? In your fingertips? Your knees? Your spleen? You don't "feel" a soul at all. You want one to exist so bad that you create the delusional experience of actually "sensing" it. But try to explain to me how you "feel" your soul. Be as descriptive as possible. Something tells me you'll have to resort to the popular, "You would never understand. You're too closed-minded." Ummm...no. Wrong answer. I want a soul to exist as bad as the next human being. I'm just not willing to lie to myself or be delusional just because the lie and delusion feel good.
| Quote: |
| How can I provide a 'logical' argument when all I have is an emotion to go on......but I do insist....that my emotion is just as tangible (OK, not logical) as your intellect. |
I don't even know what to say to this. If you think emotion and logic are equally valid tools for understanding your environment then you would be a very dangerous person if placed in a position of power. What controls your emotions? What one person experiences internally as their emotional response can be completely different than the emotional response of those around them. Logic aspires to be objective and not subjective.
| Quote: |
| I do think that we need to have a foot in both worlds if we are to get anywhere. |
Impossible if another world doesn't even exist. You believing you have your foot in both worlds doesn't make it so. And what do you mean by "if we are to get anywhere." You mean geographically? I'm an atheist and I travel quite well. Do you mean intellectually? I'm a non-believer that appears to be doing quite well intellectually. So what do you mean when you say, "to get anywhere?" Where can theists go that atheists cannot go? I suggest theists travel into internal delusions. They aren't actually going anywhere at all. They just think they are. This scares the shit out of me.
| Quote: |
| But it would be a pretty dead and meaningless world if all we knew and felt could be scientifically explained and diagnosed. |
So you believe in delusions because those delusions give your life meaning. Ok, I can accept this. It scares me, but I can accept it. But what if some of us value intellectual integrity over the warm fuzzies that the God delusion provides?
And who says this world would be dead and meaningless if everything could be explained by science? You? This is your opinion? What about those of us that finds it immensely fascinating to explore the natural world and try to figure out how things work scientifically? What if I told you we don't find scientific discovery and understanding to be rendering the world dead and meaningless? Is your worldview more right than mine? So believing in God make you feel good. Not believing in God makes me feel good. Either God exists or God doesn’t exist. One of us is right and one wrong. Something tells me that the truth can only be known by removing emotion from the equation and approaching the subject as objectively as possible. Anyone that is able to do this will conclude that atheism is the better answer….in my opinion.
| Quote: |
| Hitler would have been right for a start.....let's create a super-race....let's exterminate all those who do not meet our criteria.....as strong, intelligent superbeings.... |
I sure hope you're not equating atheism with Hitler. I'm not trying to create a super-race. But I am trying to better our species and world by teaching people to think more effectively and get their heads out of the sand. Are you against violence and brutality? What!? You're trying to eradicate something!? How dare you! What...are you trying to create a master-race!?
I'm trying to eradicate delusional thinking. You’re trying to eradicate violence and brutality. Both are bad things. Delusional thinking is what causes grown mature adults to strap bombs to their bodies and detonate themselves in the public square. Delusional thinking causes grown mature adults to pull 85 year old women out of their homes and burn them alive at the stake for practicing witchcraft. Delusional thinking causes the Pope to condemn the use of condoms when this world is suffering from an AIDS epidemic, over population and all sorts of associated problems.
Delusions are dangerous and just because a particular delusion appears to do more good than harm it should still be wiped out. Who knows when that same delusion will turn into something more sinister. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Penelope  Stupendously Brilliant Silver Contributor


Usergroups: None
Joined: 02 Oct 2007

Posts: 737
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Cheshire, England

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 11:52 am Post subject:
|
|
|
Chris, you took the trouble to answer my initial post...point-by-point and I have been trying to think of a way to return the compliment.
This is not about point scoring.....it is about trying to understand something about one another.....and I believe in morphic resonance...so if we can get to grips on BT with what is going on.....maybe it will echo on through others who are thinking about 'What the hell is wrong with us'.
OK - so here goes. I don't know if you will read it....but it will do me some good to try to defend my faith.
Do you know the old film of 'Hans Christian Andersen' with Danny Kay?
In that film there is a song which goes:-
Inch Worm, Inch Worm, Measuring the Marigolds
Seems to me you might stop and see how beautiful they are.....
Now, I do realise that we can't all sit back admiring the beauty of the Marigolds in open mouthed wonder.....
No, we must measure them and weigh them and try to understand what makes them be......
The Marigolds (of course) here are a metaphore for the World.
I, being a person who is too much inclined to step back in amazement and just enjoy them, have also looked (to the best of my ability) at the mathematics. The mathematics are also very beautiful.
What is it in us Chris, that can do all the weighing and measuring and rationalising.....but then just step back in breathless amazement at the beauty of it all. What is it in us that perceives the beauty?
That is what I call 'the soul'. That is why I say.....you can only feel it.
We must measure and weigh and explore and try to understand what makes the world tic....but there is something else in us...that is not about analysis.......it is about soul.
And I am so anxious to preserve that sense of wonder......because I believe we need that....as much as we need a sense of exploration......
That is why I say we need 'balance'. And I do believe that the very erudite Robert Tulip and Thomas Hood....whom we are privilidged to encounter on this website.....are scientists....with big explorative brains....but I do believe they have a sense of wonder too.....
Basically.....what is it in us....that appreciates the beauty, the humour, the absurd?.....because computers, machines, sure don't feel the way we do. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Penelope  Stupendously Brilliant Silver Contributor


Usergroups: None
Joined: 02 Oct 2007

Posts: 737
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
Location: Cheshire, England

|
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 12:11 pm Post subject:
|
|
|
Chris said:-
| Quote: |
| So you said you feel sorry for people that cannot sense an eternal soul. |
I DID NOT SAY THIS!!!!
I only might have said, (although I didn't) that I find it hard to understand people who do not 'feel' their own soul.....seperate that is, from the mind.
I am not apportioning blame here......not even to myself.
| Quote: |
| How does an infinite universe lead you to believe in the Christian God? |
I never said anything (on this thread anyway) about belief in a Christian God. I really don't think it is possible, or even necessary to try to pigeonhole and categorise what God is........
If we lived and behaved as though our souls were eternal......because we sure as hell....don't have finite rationality.....like computers and machines. If we had a sense of 'endlessness' (for the want of a better word)...then it alters our whole concept of what life is about. I think it alters it for the better.........if we could only stop arguing about the bloody nuts and bolts.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
jaywalker  Gaining experience
Usergroups: None
Joined: 07 Apr 2008
Posts: 75
Thanks Given: 0 Received: 0 in 0 Posts
Gender: 
|
Posted: Thu Jun 05, 2008 7:09 am Post subject: Atheism & Freethought Explored
|
|
|
| Penelope, I agree with all that,but don't smell the Marigolds. Here they are called 'Stinkertjes'. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
DWill  Amazingly Intelligent
Usergroups: None
Joined: 31 Jan 2008
| |