Looking for Spinoza: Joy, Sorrow and
the Feeling Brain by Antonio Damasio
|
Book Reviews
Amazon.com
As he seeks to unlock the secrets of
such things as joy and sorrow, Antonio Damasio pursues
a unifying theory in Looking for Spinoza. Why Spinoza?
The philosopher, whom Damasio calls a "protobiologist,"
firmly linked mind and body, paving the way for modern
ideas of neurophysiology. Damasio examines this linkage,
which ran counter to all scientific and religious thinking
of Spinoza's day, and lays out the reasoning and evidence
behind its truth. As he has in his previous books on
the subject (Descartes' Error and The Feeling of What
Happens), Damasio is careful to use clear examples from
life to explain the often dry and difficult science
of the brain. When he wants readers to understand, for
instance, brain stem control of emotions, he offers
an Oliver Sacks-style case study of a man whose stroke
left him unable to keep from bursting into tears or
laughter at inappropriate times.
Damasio also defines his terms, which is crucial, as
he means something very specific when he says feeling
("always hidden, like all mental images")
instead of emotion ("actions or movements... visible
to others as they occur in the face, in the voice, in
specific behaviors"). Using an impressive array
of biological and psychological research, Damasio makes
a compelling case for his idea of the feeling brain
as crucial for survival and sense of self. But this
isn't just a book about brain science. It's a record
of an intellectual journey, a diary of Damasio's musings
about history, philosophy, and Spinoza's life, all wrapped
up in a simply astonishing explanation of a subject
most of us don't give a thought to--the feelings that
we live by.
Publisher's Weekly
The third in a series that began with
Descartes' Error, this book deftly combines recent advances
in neuroscience with charged meditations on foundational
17th-century philosopher Baruch Spinoza, and the result
is Damasio's fullest report so far on the nature of
feelings. A Salk Institute professor and head of the
department of neurology at the University of Iowa Medical
Center, Damasio makes a useful distinction between emotions,
which are publicly observable body states, and feelings,
which are mental events observable only to the person
having them. Based on neuroscience research he and others
have done, Damasio argues that an episode of emoting
begins with an emotionally "competent" stimulus
(such as an attractive person or a scary house) that
the organism automatically appraises as conducive to
survival or well-being (a good thing) or not conducive
(bad). This appraisal takes the form of a complex array
of physiological reactions (e.g., quickening heartbeat,
tensing facial muscles), which is mapped in the brain.
From that map, a feeling arises as "an idea of
the body when it is perturbed by the emoting process."
Because they "bear witness to the state of life
deep within," feelings are a vital guide to decision-making.
Damasio goes on to connect his own views to Spinoza's
and sympathize with that thinker's "secular religiosity,"
which identified God with nature. He ends by discussing
spiritual feelings, which he relates to "the sense
that the organism is functioning with the greatest possible
perfection." Given his professional background,
it is not surprising that Damasio is more persuasive
when talking neuroscience than philosophy. But overall,
he succeeds in making the latest brain research accessible
to the general reader, while his passionate Spinozist
reflections make that data relevant to everyday life.
Please consider joining our online
book discussion forum and reading group!
Looking
for Spinoza: Joy, Sorrow and the Feeling Brain by Antonio
Damasio
|