Please support our free community by making a credit card donation through our secure PayPal account. We appreciate and depend on the generosity of our members. Thank you!
These guys look like what we call “bugs” in the prison system (basically wackos who were put into prison because they are too violent to be in a mental institution), that dance (or whatever you call it) looks a lot like a bug when they spaz out.
Gee Frank, that sounded a bit judgmental, if not actually hateful. I’d definitely call that dance and, though I didn’t see anything really astonishing in the videos Chris posted, the guy in LanDroid’s is extraordinary. I can’t imagine the muscle work going on there—out of this world strength and power, combined with agility, control and flexibility. Actually, Frank, with your background in martial arts, I’d think you’d appreciate the concentration and work that goes into making one’s body perform that way. I think, at least, your martial arts training would certainly keep you from comparing such people—well any people really—to “bugs.”
First of all, I was only commenting on the first video, I did not watch the second.
And while it may technically be defined as dancing, I certainly would not compare it with anything that takes discipline, precision or years of practice like ballet or karate.
Lastly… this was not a hateful comment, if you had seen a “bug” wig out I doubt that even you could deny the similarities.
Well, technical or no Frank, it’s dance. It’s rhythmic body movement accompanied by music. As I said, I wouldn’t necessarily call the first video good dancing, but it’s dance. As for the comparison I drew to the skill and body mechanics in martial arts, I was speaking specifically to the third video.
Frank wrote:
Lastly… this was not a hateful comment, if you had seen a “bug” wig out I doubt that even you could deny the similarities.
Trust me, I probably wouldn’t call people, any people, bugs. When working relatively closely with people who are living in imprisonment, some of whom will be spending the rest of their lives there, I think it’s dangerous to incorporate a language that further degrades their humanity. And I mean dangerous for me. I’ve seen mentally ill people have episodes both in a courtroom and in transport. I hope I would never call them bugs. Distancing myself from such people’s humanity destroys a bit of my own. I try to be always aware of that when dealing with defendants on a day-to-day basis, however repulsive the acts that brought them before the court might have been.
Rose
Well, technical or no Frank, its dance. It’s rhythmic body movement accompanied by music.
In my opinion it did not amount to much more than free form flailing, but if you want to call it dance that’s cool with me.
Quote:
Rose
As I said, I wouldn’t necessarily call the first video good dancing, but its dance. As for the comparison I drew to the skill and body mechanics in martial arts, I was speaking specifically to the third video.
Like I said, I did not watch the other videos.
Quote:
Rose
Trust me; I probably wouldn’t call people, any people, bugs. When working relatively closely with people who are living in imprisonment, some of whom will be spending the rest of their lives there, I think it’s dangerous to incorporate a language that further degrades their humanity.
Then you should talk to the inmates about it... “Bug” was coined by them, it is accepted term in that enviroment that is older than I am and if you don’t talk the inmate’s language you will not go far in corrections.
But it was insensitive at least. Maybe I should have said "loony inmate spazing out".
Quote:
Rose
I’ve seen mentally ill people have episodes both in a courtroom and in transport. I hope I would never call them bugs.
That’s fine for most people but like I just stated I have to speak that language if I want to understand the inmates.
It never even occurred to me that comparing one thing to another (when they are in fact similar) would be constituted as hateful or judgmental, after all I was not commenting on the dancers themselves, only comparing the dance they were performing with something else I was familiar with.
Quote:
Rose
Distancing myself from such people’s humanity destroys a bit of my own. I try to be always aware of that when dealing with defendants on a day-to-day basis, however repulsive the acts that brought them before the court might have been.
I do not distance myself from anyone’s humanity, I simply use the terms that are accepted in that environment. And believe it or not I can make the distinction.
I treat all inmates the same, I mirror the respect that they give me, which has (so far) been good.
BookTalk.org is a book discussion group, also known as a reading group or book club. We read and talk about fiction books and non-fiction books, as a group. Live author chats where book group members can interact with and interview authors are common. We often give away free books to our members in book giveaway contests. Our booktalks are open to everybody who enjoys booktalk. Booktalk is a free online reading group that features quality book reviews, resources for readers and book lovers. Discussing books is our passion. Fiction chat and non-fiction chat, book forum, literature forum, or reading forum...call us what you will. Register a free book club account today Suggest either fiction or nonfiction books. Authors and publishers are welcome to plug their books or ask for an author chat or interview.
