How We Believe: Science, Skepticism and the Search
for God by Michael Shermer
|
Book Reviews
Amazon.com
One hundred years ago social scientists
predicted that belief in God would decrease by the year
2000. "In fact ... the opposite is has occurred,"
Shermer writes in his introduction. "Never
in history have so many, and such a high percentage
of the population, believed in God. Not only is God
not dead as Nietzche proclaimed, but he has never been
more alive."
Why do so many believe in the existence of something
so inexplicable? That's exactly what Michael Shermer
answers in this comprehensive, intelligent, and highly
readable discussion about the nature of faith. "People
believe in God because the evidence of their senses
tell them so," claims Shermer, who is the
publisher of Skeptics magazine. Having been a believer
and a student of the history of science, Shermer
(now an agnostic) is more interested in knowing why
and how people believe in God rather than trying to
prove who's right or wrong. As a result, this book is
not only even-handed and thorough, it is also destined
to become a timeless contribution to spirituality as
well as science.
Publisher's Weekly
Michael Shermer, who teaches critical
thinking at Occidental College and is perhaps
best known as the director of the Skeptics Society
and publisher of Skeptic magazine, approaches
religion not primarily as a delusion to be debunked
but as a phenomenon to be explained. Shermer wonders
why religious belief, traditional theistic belief in
particular, remains widespread in contemporary America,
confounding expectations that progress in science and
technology should bring a corresponding decline in faith.
One way to discover why people believe is to ask them,
and Shermer has compiled original survey data
to support his analysis. One noteworthy finding is that,
although theists tend to explain their own faith in
rational terms (e.g., observing design in nature or
a pattern of God's activity in daily life), they explain
the theistic beliefs of "most other people"
primarily in emotional or pragmatic terms (e.g., faith
brings comfort and hope). Shermer maintains that
while believers' first-person awareness is misleading,
their third-person perspective gets it right: religion
can be explained quite adequately in functional terms.
He reviews a range of theories from anthropology, evolutionary
psychology and cognitive science that analyze religion
as a means to social harmony or psychological stability.
Although Shermer's arguments will probably not
be decisive for debates between nonbelievers and believers
(who generally agree that religion has strong pragmatic
benefits), both will be able to appreciate this readable
and generally fair-minded treatment of a subject that
often provokes contentious dispute.
Please consider joining our online
book discussion forum and reading group!
How
We Believe: Science, Skepticism and the Search for God
by Michael Shermer
|