I deleted my post because I didn't want to create a side diversion totally off base from the discussion you and Stawhre are having.Interbane wrote:We don't know. How about the big bounce? Infinite repetitions of the big bang? I believe no one knows. If someone claims to know, then they don't know what the word 'know' means.Enlighten me then, as an atheist, what do you believe existed before the big bang?
Purpose is a human invention. The onus is on you to show that it exists outside humanity. I'd have to say that the most honest answer here is that we don't know. But what we do know is that most if not all instances where people claim to see purpose, there isn't actually purpose. Meaning, if there is purpose in our universe, we haven't seen it yet.Is there purpose in Nature, or is it purposeless?
Sounds like Robert Tulip.All that is, is eternal and always will be.
This has and continues ad naus.
That's all.