Fundamentalist Atheism

Interbane · Posted: Tue Sep 30, 2008 8:23 pm Post subject:

Dwill: "What makes you think that science and religion are commensurate in the first place?"

Religion, or a specific religion. Let's say Christianity. Do you really think they could both be true?

Dwill: "The most we can hope for is partial objectivity, as contradictory as the two words might be together. We are stuck with minds that can never be autonomously rational."

That would ruin the word "objectivity." It is but a word, used to describe an idea. I think it is your understanding of the concept that is slightly off, no offense. It's an extremely controversial term in philosophy, so to claim to know the meaning with any confidence is overconfidence.

I have to ask what you mean again... what do you mean by "autonomously rational"? Are you referring to our actions in light of a mechanist view? If the entire universe is a robot, cannot a robot understand it?

DWill · Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2008 7:43 pm Post subject:

Dwill: "What makes you think that science and religion are commensurate in the first place?"

Interbane: "Religion, or a specific religion. Let's say Christianity. Do you really think they could both be true?"

What I mean is that for one thing (in this case science) to substitute for another thing (religion), the two have to be commensurate, that is reasonably equivalent in intention or purpose. I think this is not true of the relationship between science and religion. That is why many people "believe in" both, why scientists with religious beliefs are no rarity. Science and religion answer to entirely different purposes and needs.

Dwill: "The most we can hope for is partial objectivity, as contradictory as the two words might be together. We are stuck with minds that can never be autonomously rational."

Interbane: "That would ruin the word "objectivity." It is but a word, used to describe an idea. I think it is your understanding of the concept that is slightly off, no offense. It's an extremely controversial term in philosophy, so to claim to know the meaning with any confidence is overconfidence."

It would demote the word "objectivity," I admit, but it remains useful. I don't think I'm getting into philosophy here. I'm just saying that our minds do not have the ability to examine themselves from an objective point of view. We have no way to get away from either biases or distortions of thought and perception. The opposite point of view has been called "the myth of the autonomous rational mind." Going back to your post I first commented on, you said that "objectively" either science or religion had to true. Who is going to give us such an "objective" view? I say no one. Thanks for discussing this.
DWill

Interbane · Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2008 11:08 pm Post subject:

Dwill: "What I mean is that for one thing (in this case science) to substitute for another thing (religion), the two have to be commensurate"

Of course they don't. If the barest philosophical overlapping between the two is critical to the truth of either, they need not be commensurate.

Dwill: "I'm just saying that our minds do not have the ability to examine themselves from an objective point of view."

They sure don't. There's also no way to absolutely trust either our sense datum or our critical thinking conclusions. Before we can even define the term "objectivity", we must have faith in our sense datum with respect to communicating with other people. The last part is critical, since it is the communication with other people that validates our own perceptions. I trust more firmly that I just saw an octopus(rather than it being a hallucination) when another person confirms it. Needless to say, it is merely a faith that should be had and not certainty. We could always be the psychotic one without knowing it and be dreaming up our entire reality.

With that said, I don't think the term objectivity needs to be demoted. I think you need to replace your conceptualization of it with the phrase "absolute objectivity" and leave "objectivity" alone.


	FORUMS	ABOUT	BOOKS	VIDEOS	TRANSCRIPTS	LINKS	BLOGS	DONATE	CONTACT